| Name | Slices | Acceptable Toppings |
| Jane | 2 | Mushroom, onion, peppers, olives |
| Lisa | 3 | Pepperoni, ham, pineapple |
| Taylor | 3 | Extra cheese, pepperoni, sausage, bacon |
| Chris | 2 | Mushroom, sausage, bacon, ham, onion, peppers |
| Alyssa | 1 | Pepperoni, bacon |
| Will | 2 | Extra cheese, sausage, bacon, onion, peppers, olives |
| Jessica | 2 | Pepperoni, bacon, ham, pineapple, onion, peppers |